Photo of Melanie Engle

Melanie Engle

Professional Beauty Expert


Featured On:

  • MTV
  • Vogue
  • E Entertainment
If you are one of the many of women suffering from lash envy, an instant cure is as simple as finding the right mascara. Mascara enhances your eyelashes creating the super hot look of long thick lashes for which every woman is looking. Armed with professional knowledge, you can easily find the ultimate mascara that will give you the super sexy lashes you deserve. After weeks of product testing, I have discovered many amazing mascaras that exceeded my expectations.

Mascara Formulas:
What is the secret to finding the ultimate formula for you? It ultimately depends on the lashes you are starting with. An honest evaluation is your first step. Examine your lashes to determine the qualities you will need to look for. Do you need to make your lashes longer, thicker, or darker? With so many mascara formulas on the market, your possibilities are seemingly endless. You will find formulas such as water resistant, lengthening, thickening, conditioning, tubes, or smudge resistant that will end all of your lash woes.

Although black is the most popular color, you have many options to choose from to make your eye color pop. Brown black and brown are the most natural looking. Fashion colors come and go, but the current trends are plum, navy, and green. Some lines even have clear mascara that works well for beginners.

Your perfect prescription:
Short lashes - Look for a lengthening formula that will make your lashes appear that they go on for miles.
Thin lashes - A thickening formula will make your lashes appear full and luscious.
Dry or brittle lashes - Conditioning mascaras will stop the breakage that can make lashes appear shorter.
Contact wearers - A gentle basic mascara is your best choice. Water resistant or lengthening formula’s can get caught under your contacts and cannot be broken down by your tears.
Athletes and those who may tear - If you plan on crying or perspiring, water resistant is always your best formula choice.
Oily skin - Try one of the new tube formulas that won’t be broken down by your bodies natural oils.
Brown eyes - Black, Brown Black
Green eyes - Plum, Forest
Blue eyes - Navy

After applying your eye makeup, use mascara as your finishing touch. Always remember to curl your lashes before applying the mascara to prevent breakage. Coat both sides of your lashes for the fullest effect. Do not try to go all the way to the root or you’ll end up with mascara on your lids. Then, gently sweep the brush up through the lashes. This will help evenly coat the lashes and stop clumps. For longer looking lashes, concentrate on the tips of lashes. For thicker looking lashes, apply more color from the base to the midpoint of lashes. You can apply up to three coats to enhance the lashes, but do not let dry between coats.

Most companies recommend using a separate eye makeup remover at night to remove all traces of eye makeup. If a water resistant mascara is your weapon of choice, you will need to use one specifically formulated for that type. The new tube type of mascaras simply need a combination of water and pressure and the tubes glide right off the lashes.

Eye Do’s:
Remember to discard your mascara every three months. An easy way to remember is to purchase a new one with the start of every season.
Keep your mascara to yourself. Never share your mascara with anyone.
Twirl the wand in the tube instead of “pumping” the wand in and out of the tube, you will add air and dry the product out.

Best of the Best:
Women tend to be completely obsessed with their mascara. And after trying these mascaras, I can certainly understand why. The perfect mascara is like your best friend, always there when you need it, and will never flake on you. Department store divas be on alert: these are the best mascaras money can buy.

With the best mascara, you'll cure lash envy. We recommend the best waterproof mascar, best lengthening mascar and the best volumizing mascara so you can have the lashes you've longed for.

Best Mascaras by Melanie Engle

The Best You Can Get

  • Dior Diorshow

    Melanie says: Considered the couture mascara, Diorshow is the most fashionable by far. Hot off the runways of NYC’s Fashion Week, women are demanding the show stopping lashes only Dior could create. After hearing all of the buzz, I couldn’t wait to get my hands on a tube of this. Dior definitely showed me the way to super glam lashes.

    • Volumizing
    • Lengthening
    • Curling
    • Colors include Black, Azure Blue, Chestnut
  • Lancome Definicils

    Melanie says: Lancolme is the King (or should I say Queen) of mascara. With eleven different formulas, you will be able to find the right formula for you. I love Definicils because the perfect amount of mascara is deposited in each stroke. Definicals is also available in a waterproof and pro formula.

    • Lengthens
    • Separates
    • Colors include Black, Deep Brown, Navy, Brown
  • shu uemura Fiber Xtension Lengthening

    Melanie says: shu uemura has created the ultimate in lengthening formulas. The fibers in this mascara made my short lashes so long they were touching my sunglasses. I also love the way it just glided onto my lashes.

    • Lengthening
    • Extra black color
  • Blinc Kiss Me

    Melanie says: Kiss Me Mascara is the innovative newest type of mascara that encapsulates the lashes creating perfectly formed tubes around each individual lash. This mascara absolutely will not budge all day, and all night for that matter. If you have smudging problems, you absolutely must try this unbelievable product. A simple combination of water and pressure is all it takes to remove this, no need for harsh eye makeup removers.

    • Innovative tube formula
    • Water-resistant
    • Colors include Black, Dark Brown, Medium Brown, Blue, Purple
  • Benefit BADgal Lash

    Melanie says: A huge brush applies more mascara in only one easy coat. I have never had such full looking lashes in my life and swear I will never have to wear false eyelashes again. You’ll be a Badgal too if you try this one!

    • Thickening
    • Black color

You will be happy with any of these

  • Max Factor 2000 Calorie

    Melanie says: This one coat wonder made my lashes look huge! I wanted to feel super sexy for a night of dancing. Not only did I not have a smudge on me, but it came off with only my facial cleanser. A great choice for contact wearers or if you’re eyes are sensitive.

    • Thickening
    • Smudge proof
    • Colors include Rich Black, Black Brown, Soft Black
  • Maybelline Great Lash

    Melanie says: This is the one mascara that more women swear by. This went on easily and separated every one of my lashes. My lashes didn’t feel brittle or dry. The curved brush seemed to curl my lashes making my eyes look lifted. This one was as gentle to my lashes as it was to my pocketbook.

    • Lengthens
    • Thickens
    • Conditioning
    • Colors include Black, Brown, Blue, Clear
  • L’Oreal Voluminous Waterproof Volume Building

    Melanie says: A patented brush ensures one coat is all it will take to get thick and rich looking lashes. As a professional makeup artist, I love to use Voluminous for wedding makeup. It gives a super dramatic that brides are looking for and never runs. Panthenol and Ceramide-R leaves the lashes conditioned and soft. At this price, I won’t cry when it’s time to throw it away.

    • Waterproof
    • Thickening
    • Colors include Black, Brown Black
  • CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume Blasting

    Melanie says: This huge patent-pending brush coats every single lash with the perfect amount of product. I used two coats and loved the amount of lashes it looked like I had. This super dramatic mascara is perfect for dramatic evening look. Lash Blast easily came off with soap and water. I felt I got the most bang for my buck with this one.

    • Thickening
    • Colors include Brown, Black, Black Brown, Very Black
  • Maybelline Full ‘N Soft

    Melanie says: I loved how soft my lashes felt after applying it. My lashes can look and feel brittle on the tips and this made them feel healthy and conditioned. Full ‘N Soft looked natural and didn’t clump. I like this one for my every day mascara.

    • Thickening
    • Also available in waterproof
    • Colors include Very Black, Black, Brownish Black

Related Articles

For the best mascara, look no further. We recommend the best waterproof mascara and other types of mascara that will lengthen and volumize your lashes. In addition to the best lengthening mascara and best volumizing mascara, we also detail just what type of makeup you need for the condition of those maybe-not-so lush lashes. Choose the best cosmetics always at the best price with our help.